The 5,000-Year Story

The history most people were never taught

Slavery did not start in America.

5,000 years old, at least From the clay tablets of ancient Sumer, about 3200 BC, to the present day.[1]

For thousands of years slavery took people of every color, on every continent, including millions of white Europeans. The 246 years of slavery in America were real and terrible. They were also one chapter of a much older human story.

Scroll
An English ship fighting Barbary corsairs, who enslaved European sailors. Willem van de Velde the Younger, about 1685.
THE MAIN POINT

Slavery was not only the last 200 years in the USA, and it was not only done to Black people.

It happened to white people, and to people of every color, for thousands of years.

5,000+
years that people have been enslaved, as far back as written records go
2,500+
years that white Europeans were bought and sold, from ancient Greece to the 1800s
246
years of slavery in what became the United States (1619 to 1865)

Slavery in America lasted 246 years. White Europeans were enslaved for more than ten times as long. For most of human history, slaves were not chosen by the color of their skin. They were people who lost a war, got caught in a raid, or fell into debt.[2]

Scroll through 5,000 years of slavery

USA 1619 to 1865: 246 years ▾
About 3200 to 3000 BC · Sumer (Iraq)

The oldest written records already list slaves

Some of the earliest writing on Earth, clay tablets from the city of Uruk, already lists male and female slaves, many of them captives from the hills. By the time people learned to write, slavery was already there.

About 2100 to 1754 BC · Mesopotamia

The first law codes set rules for slaves

The law code of Ur-Nammu and, later, the Code of Hammurabi treat slavery as a normal part of life: how slaves were bought, punished and freed.

About 1600 to 1000 BC · Egypt and China

Captives in Egypt's mines, captives in Shang China

Egypt's pharaohs put foreign captives to work in mines and quarries. In Shang dynasty China, war captives, many of them Qiang people from the west, were sacrificed in royal rituals.

About 800 to 146 BC · Greece

Democracy in Athens ran on slaves

Athens held tens of thousands of slaves, many from Thrace and Scythia, and worked many of them to death in its silver mines. Sparta enslaved fellow Greeks, the helots.

509 BC to AD 476 · Rome

Rome held millions of slaves at once

Gauls, Britons, Germans, Greeks, Thracians, Jews and Syrians: anyone Rome conquered could be sold. Their children were born slaves.

AD 600s to 1900s · The Islamic world

Slave trades that lasted 1,300 years

Africans, Slavs, Greeks, Turks, Persians and Indians were carried across the Sahara, the Red Sea, the Indian Ocean and the Black Sea for more than a thousand years.

793 to 1066 · The Viking age

Vikings captured and sold the Irish and the English

Viking raiders took men, women and children from Ireland, Britain and Eastern Europe. Dublin, a Viking base, became one of Europe's main slave markets.

800s to 1000s · Eastern Europe

"Slav" became the word "slave"

So many Slavic people were captured and sold that, in medieval Latin, the word for Slav came to mean slave. English took the word from there.

1086 · England

One in ten people in England was a slave

William the Conqueror's great survey, the Domesday Book, recorded about one slave for every ten people it counted.

1250 to 1517 · Egypt

Slave soldiers ruled Egypt

The Mamluks, boys bought from the steppes and the Caucasus and trained as soldiers, seized power and ruled Egypt for more than 250 years.

1440s to 1860s · The Atlantic

About 12.5 million Africans shipped to the Americas

African kingdoms sold captives to European traders, who shipped them across the Atlantic. Most went to Brazil and the Caribbean.

1400s to 1700s · Ukraine, Poland, Russia

Up to 2 million taken by the Crimean slave raids

Crimean Tatar horsemen drove Ukrainians, Poles and Russians to the slave markets of Crimea, to be sold on to the Ottoman Empire.

1500s to 1830 · North Africa

Barbary pirates enslaved a million or more Europeans

Corsairs from Algiers, Tunis, Tripoli and Morocco raided ships and coasts from Italy to Iceland and sold their white captives.

1619 to 1865 · What became the USA

246 years

From the first Africans sold in Virginia in 1619 to the 13th Amendment in 1865. A real and terrible chapter, and a short one on the scale of this timeline.

1888 · Brazil

The last country in the Americas ends slavery

Brazil, which received more enslaved Africans than any other country, freed its slaves 23 years after the United States.

1930s to 1950s · Europe

Slave labor returns to Europe

Nazi Germany forced an estimated 10 to 13 million people into labor, most of them Poles and Soviet citizens, and about 18 million passed through the Soviet Gulag camps.

1962 · Saudi Arabia

Slavery is finally made illegal

Almost a hundred years after the United States, Saudi Arabia abolished slavery by royal decree. Mauritania followed in 1981 and made it a crime only in 2007.

Today · Everywhere

About 50 million people live in modern slavery

Forced labor and forced marriage still trap people of every color, on every continent, today.

Look at the red sliver

That is the 246 years of slavery in America.

It is about 5 percent of this timeline. The other 95 percent, more than 4,600 years before it and the years since, is the part most people were never taught.

White people were slaves too

For thousands of years, the slaves were often white Europeans

Ask people to picture a slave and most will picture one thing. But for most of recorded history, the person in chains could just as easily be a Greek farmer, a Gaul, an Irish girl, an English villager, a Ukrainian boy or an Italian fisherman. Here is their story, century by century.

Just some of the European peoples who were enslaved

  • Greeks
  • Thracians
  • Scythians
  • Gauls
  • Britons
  • Germans
  • Slavs
  • Irish
  • English
  • Scots
  • Icelanders
  • Italians
  • Spaniards
  • Portuguese
  • French
  • Dutch
  • Ukrainians
  • Poles
  • Lithuanians
  • Russians
  • Circassians
  • Georgians
  • Serbs
  • Bulgarians
  • Albanians
  • Bosnians
About 800 to 146 BC

Ancient Greece: democracy built on slaves

65,000 to 100,000slaves in Athens and its countryside at the peak, by the usual estimates. Nobody counted them.[3]

Athens, the birthplace of democracy, depended on slave labor in its homes, workshops and fields. Perhaps 15,000 to 20,000 slaves dug silver in the mines of Laurion, the harshest work in Greece. Many came from Thrace and Scythia in the north.

Sparta went further and held fellow Greeks in bondage. Its helots, conquered Greeks who farmed Sparta's land, far outnumbered the Spartans themselves: at the battle of Plataea, Herodotus says, each Spartan soldier brought seven.[3]

Ancient Greek clay tablet showing workers digging in a pit or mine
Greek clay tablet showing workers in a pit or mine
509 BC to AD 476

Rome: millions in chains

About 5 millionpeople enslaved at one time in the Roman Empire, by one careful estimate. The US held about 4 million in 1860.[4]

Rome enslaved the peoples it conquered: Gauls, Britons, Germans, Spaniards, Greeks, Thracians, Jews and Syrians. Caesar himself reported selling 53,000 people of one Gallic tribe in a single sale, and Plutarch claimed his wars in Gaul took a million prisoners. In Roman Italy, historians estimate that one in five to one in three people was a slave, and a slave's children were born slaves.

When Spartacus, a Thracian sold as a gladiator, led a slave revolt in 73 BC, Rome crushed it and crucified 6,000 captured rebels all along the road from Capua to Rome.[4]

Roman carving of captives in chains
Roman carving of chained captives
800s to 1000s

The word "slave" comes from "Slav"

Slav→sclavus→esclave→slave

In the early Middle Ages so many Slavic people from Eastern Europe were captured and sold, to Byzantium, to Muslim Spain and to Baghdad, that their name turned into the word itself. In medieval Latin, sclavus meant both "Slav" and "slave". French made it esclave, and English made it slave.[5]

The English word "slave" still carries the name of the Eastern European people who were sold.

sclavus
Medieval Latin for a Slav, and for a slave
The word itself remembers who was sold
793 to 1066

The Vikings: Dublin was a slave market

Viking raiders seized Irish, English and Scottish men, women and children and sold them across Scandinavia, Iceland and beyond. Dublin, a Viking base from the 840s, became one of the main slave markets of north-western Europe.[6]

Iceland's own DNA tells the story: about 60 percent of the island's founding mothers had Irish or Scottish ancestry, and many were probably brought as captives. Iceland's Westman Islands are still named after Irish slaves who, the old Book of Settlements says, killed their master and fled there.[6]

Painting of Viking ships
Viking ships
1086

England: one in ten people was a slave

1 in 10of the people counted in the Domesday Book were slaves[7]

When William the Conqueror surveyed his new kingdom in 1086, about one in every ten people recorded was a slave. English slaves were shipped out of Bristol and sold in Ireland. A church council in London banned the trade in 1102, and in about 1170 an Irish church council ordered every English slave in Ireland set free.[7]

A page of the Domesday Book
The Domesday Book, 1086
1400s to 1700s

Eastern Europe: up to 2 million taken by the Crimean raiders

1 to 2 millionUkrainians, Poles, Lithuanians and Russians carried off by Crimean Tatar and Nogai raids, 1500 to 1700[8]

For three centuries Crimean Tatar horsemen raided the farmlands of Ukraine, Poland and Russia. They drove their captives to the slave markets of Crimea, where many were sold on to the Ottoman Empire. Nobody knows the exact total; one careful estimate is about 2 million people between 1500 and 1700.

According to tradition, one of them was a girl from what is now Ukraine, known as Roxelana. Sold into the Sultan's harem, she became the wife of Suleiman the Magnificent.[8]

Engraving of a Tatar raid on Poland in 1666
Portrait traditionally said to be Roxelana
Tatar raiders with captives
1300s to 1900s

The Ottoman Empire: the boy levy and the harem

Under the devshirme, Ottoman officials took Christian boys from the villages of the Balkans, Greeks, Serbs, Albanians, Bulgarians and Bosnians, converted them and raised them as Janissary soldiers and servants of the Sultan.[9]

Circassian girls from the Caucasus were sold into harems, a trade that went on into the early 1900s. In the Ottoman slave hierarchy, white Circassian and Georgian women ranked above Africans.[9]

Ottoman miniature painting
Ottoman miniature, 1500s
1500s to 1830

Barbary pirates: a million or more white slaves

1 to 1.25 millionEuropeans enslaved in North Africa between 1530 and 1780, by historian Robert C. Davis's estimate[10]

From Algiers, Tunis, Tripoli and Morocco, corsairs captured ships and raided coasts from Italy and Spain to England, Ireland and even Iceland. In 1627 raiders carried off nearly 400 people from Iceland. In 1631 they took about 107 villagers from Baltimore in Ireland, and almost none ever came home.

In the 1600s the Barbary states held about 25,000 to 35,000 European captives at a time, most of them in Algiers. Miguel de Cervantes, who later wrote Don Quixote, spent five years as a slave there.[10]

Engraving of Christian captives being sold as slaves in a square in Algiers
Portrait of Miguel de Cervantes
Christian captives sold as slaves in Algiers
1785 to 1830

American sailors were enslaved too

307men of the USS Philadelphia held captive in Tripoli for 19 months, 1803 to 1805[11]

From 1785, American merchant sailors were seized and enslaved in Algiers; in 1796 the United States paid a huge ransom and tribute to free 83 of them. In 1803 the frigate USS Philadelphia ran aground off Tripoli and its whole crew was held until a $60,000 ransom was paid. Thomas Jefferson sent the Navy and the Marines, the "shores of Tripoli" in the Marines' Hymn, and in 1815 James Madison sent them back.

British and Dutch warships bombarded Algiers in 1816 and freed more than 1,000 Christian slaves there, but the trade in white slaves ended only after France conquered Algiers in 1830.[11]

Painting of the burning of the frigate Philadelphia in Tripoli harbor
The burning of the USS Philadelphia, Tripoli, 1804
1650s

Ireland and Scotland: shipped to the sugar islands

After Oliver Cromwell's conquest of Ireland, Irish prisoners, vagrants, women and children, and Scottish prisoners of war, were forced onto ships for Barbados and other colonies as bound laborers. The generally accepted estimate is about 10,000 Irish sent against their will; some older estimates go as high as 50,000.[12]

Their bondage was for a set number of years and their children were born free, which is different from the lifelong, inherited slavery forced on Africans. But they did not choose to go, and many died before their time was up.

Old map of Barbados
Barbados in the 1650s
1600s to 1700s

Half of white colonists arrived in bondage

1/2 to 2/3of white immigrants to the American colonies came as indentured servants[13]

Most were poor English, Irish, Scottish and German workers who signed away four to seven years of their lives to pay for the voyage, and some were convicts or kidnapped children. They could be bought, sold, whipped, and have their years of service extended as punishment. It was not lifelong slavery, but it was not freedom either.

An indenture was a contract of bound labor
1930s to 1950s

In living memory: Europe's slave labor camps

10 to 13 millionpeople forced to work for Nazi Germany, most of them Poles and Soviet citizens[14]

Nazi Germany forced an estimated 10 to 13 million people from across occupied Europe, most of them Poles and Soviet citizens, to work in its farms, factories and camps. After the war the Nuremberg trials charged it as a war crime under its true name: slave labor.

In the Soviet Union, about 18 million people passed through the forced labor camps of the Gulag between 1929 and 1953.[14]

Nazi Germany, 1939 to 1945Forced and slave labor from across occupied Europe
Soviet Gulag, 1929 to 1953Forced labor camps across the Soviet Union
The 20th century

Count them yourself

More white Europeans were taken than Africans were shipped to the United States

Compare the people shipped from Africa to what became the United States with the Europeans taken by just two slave trades of the same centuries.

2 to 3 millionwhite Europeans taken by just these two slave trades
vs
388,000Africans shipped to what became the United States

The number of whites, for example, who were enslaved in North Africa by the Barbary pirates exceeded the number of Africans enslaved in the United States and in the American colonies before that put together.

Thomas Sowell, economist and historian, in an interview at the Hoover Institution shown in the second video. He wrote the same in 2014: "More whites were brought as slaves to North Africa than blacks brought as slaves to the United States."[16]

Two honest notes. The European numbers are historians' estimates, not head counts, and the Barbary figure is Robert Davis's estimate, which some historians think is high. And why the US number later grew: slavery in America was hereditary, so the children of enslaved people were born enslaved. By 1860 about 4 million people were enslaved in the United States.[17] That is why the American story is about families held for generations, and why it is remembered so strongly. It does not change the main point: in the centuries when Africans were being shipped to America, millions of white Europeans were being sold in the slave markets of North Africa and the Black Sea.

See these numbers as a table
WhoWhenHow manySource
Africans shipped directly to what became the USA1619 to 1860s388,744 (estimate)[15]
Europeans enslaved by Barbary corsairs1530 to 17801,000,000 to 1,250,000[10]
Eastern Europeans taken by Crimean Tatar raids1500 to 1700about 1,000,000 to 2,000,000[8]
Enslaved people living in the USA (census)18603,953,760[17]
The 1788 plan of the slave ship Brookes, showing how captives were packed
The slave ship Brookes, 1788: the plan abolitionists used to show the horror of the crossing.

The Atlantic trade

Where the slave ships really went

About 12.5 million Africans were put on ships to the Americas between the 1500s and the 1860s, and about 10.7 million survived the crossing. Most of them never came anywhere near the United States. As the Harvard historian Henry Louis Gates Jr. has written, only about 388,000 were shipped directly to what became the US.[15]

▲ What became the USA: about 388,000 people, under 4 percent

    Of every 100 Africans who survived the crossing, about 4 were landed in what became the United States, and about 45 in Brazil. Some more reached the US second-hand through Caribbean ports.[15]

    Even in America

    Not only Black and white

    In 1830 the census recorded about 3,800 free Black Americans as owners of about 12,800 enslaved people, under 1 percent of all the enslaved. Many had bought a wife, children or other relatives and were not allowed to free them; a minority ran farms and plantations for profit.[18]

    Before the Europeans came

    Slavery was already there

    Portuguese ships began seizing people on the West African coast in 1441. When 235 captives were sold at Lagos, Portugal, in 1444, the chronicler who watched wrote that some were "white enough, fair to look upon" and others "as black as Ethiops". Slavery was already part of life in many African kingdoms, as it was in Europe, Asia and the Americas.[19]

    The difference

    What made it different

    In the Americas, slavery became tied to race: skin color alone marked a person as someone who could be enslaved, for life, and their children after them. It was also recent, ending just six or seven generations ago, and it left detailed records. That is why it is the one chapter everyone knows.

    Every color, every continent

    Every civilization enslaved someone

    Watch the routes of 5,000 years of slave trading appear, era by era. Tap a route to see who was taken.

    Swipe the map sideways to see the whole world.

    Routes are simplified to show who was taken and where they were sold, not exact paths.

    See every route as a list
      Nineteenth century print of a royal reception in the kingdom of Dahomey
      Africa

      Kingdoms that sold captives

      Powerful African states such as Dahomey, Asante and Oyo went to war for captives and sold them to European ships. In 1526 King Afonso I of Kongo wrote to the King of Portugal complaining that his own people were being seized and sold.[19]

      The Islamic world, 600s to 1900s

      The longest slave trade

      For about 1,300 years, millions of Africans were carried across the Sahara, the Red Sea and the Indian Ocean, along with Slavs, Greeks, Turks, Persians and Indians. In 869, East African slaves in Iraq, the Zanj, rose up in a revolt that lasted 14 years.[20]

      The Americas

      Before and after Columbus

      On the Pacific Northwest coast, scholars estimate that roughly 10 to 35 percent of the people in many communities were slaves taken in raids. The Comanche built an empire partly on captives. The Aztecs ran slave markets near their capital.[21]

      Asia

      From China to Korea

      More than 3,000 years ago, the kings of Shang dynasty China took war captives, many of them Qiang people, and sacrificed them in royal rituals. In Korea, hereditary slaves called nobi made up a large share of the people for centuries, often estimated at 30 to 40 percent at the peak, though the figures are rough.[21]

      Slaves who became rulers

      The Mamluks and the Janissaries

      Boys bought as slaves from the steppes and the Caucasus became the Mamluk soldiers who ruled Egypt from 1250 to 1517. The Ottoman Janissaries began as Christian slave boys too.[9]

      Africans sold other Africans to white people. That was the slave trade. That's the first thing we honestly have to admit.

      Henry Louis Gates Jr., Harvard University historian, speaking on C-SPAN (shown at the end of the second video). In The New York Times he added that historians estimate "90 percent of those shipped to the New World were enslaved by Africans and then sold to European traders."[22]
      The 1787 Wedgwood anti-slavery medallion: Am I Not a Man and a Brother?
      "Am I Not a Man and a Brother?" The 1787 badge of the movement to end slavery.

      How it finally ended

      After 5,000 years, people decided it was wrong

      A movement that began in Britain and America in the late 1700s finally turned the world against slavery, and paid for it in money and blood.

      • 1807Britain bans the slave trade. Its Navy's West Africa Squadron spends the next 60 years hunting slave ships and frees about 150,000 captives.[23]
      • 1808A US law signed in 1807 bans bringing in new slaves from abroad from 1 January 1808.[24]
      • 1833Britain abolishes slavery across most of its empire, freeing people from 1834.[23]
      • 1865The 13th Amendment ends slavery in the United States, after a civil war in which about 360,000 Union soldiers died, among them tens of thousands of the 179,000 Black soldiers who fought for freedom.[24]
      • 1888Brazil becomes the last country in the Americas to end slavery.[25]
      • 1962Saudi Arabia abolishes slavery by royal decree.[25]
      • 1981Mauritania abolishes slavery, and makes it a crime only in 2007.[25]
      • TodayAbout 50 million people are still trapped in modern slavery, in every part of the world.[26]

      The whole truth

      Slavery is not a Black story or a white story. It is a human story, 5,000 years long.

      The suffering of enslaved Africans in America was real. So was the suffering of the Greeks, Gauls, Britons, Slavs, Irish, English, Italians, Spaniards, Icelanders, Ukrainians, Poles, Russians and Americans who wore the chains before them and beside them. Telling only one chapter does not honor any of them.

      The only way to overcome that is to be honest about it, admit the truth, and then all try to do better.

      Henry Louis Gates Jr., Harvard University historian, in the same C-SPAN talk[22]

      Where this comes from

      This site is built from two documentaries by the Forgotten History channel, checked line by line against historians' published work. Every number links to its source below. Where historians disagree, the range is shown.

      The two videos

      Sources

      1. Cuneiform Digital Library Initiative (Robert K. Englund), Uruk III accounts of male and female slaves, about 3200 to 3000 BC: cdli; Schøyen Collection MS 2963, "Account of male and female slaves", about 3300 to 3200 BC: schoyencollection.com; the law codes of Ur-Nammu (about 2100 BC) and Hammurabi (about 1754 BC).
      2. University of Texas at Austin, HIS 315K, "Slavery": slavery in the classical and early medieval worlds "was not based on racial distinctions": utexas.edu; Richard Hellie, "Slavery", Encyclopaedia Britannica: britannica.com.
      3. Ben Akrigg, Population and Economy in Classical Athens (Cambridge University Press, 2019), chapter 4: doi.org; Herodotus, Histories 9.28 to 9.29.
      4. Walter Scheidel, "Human Mobility in Roman Italy, II: The Slave Population", Journal of Roman Studies 95 (2005): cambridge.org; Kyle Harper, Slavery in the Late Roman World (2011); Caesar, Gallic War 2.33; Plutarch, Life of Caesar 15: uchicago.edu; Appian, Civil Wars 1.116 to 1.120: livius.org.
      5. Online Etymology Dictionary, "slave" and "Slav": etymonline.com.
      6. Poul Holm, "The Slave Trade of Dublin, Ninth to Twelfth Centuries", Peritia 5 (1986): medievalists.net; Agnar Helgason and others, "mtDNA and the Islands of the North Atlantic", American Journal of Human Genetics 68 (2001): nih.gov; Landnámabók (the Book of Settlements).
      7. Fordham University, Internet Medieval Sourcebook, "Anglo-Saxon Slavery" (at least ten percent of the population; William of Malmesbury on Bristol): fordham.edu; Council of Armagh decree on English slaves: fordham.edu; John S. Moore, "Domesday Slavery", Anglo-Norman Studies 11 (1989).
      8. Mikhail Kizilov, "Slaves, Money Lenders, and Prisoner Guards", Journal of Jewish Studies 58 (2007), reporting Dariusz Kołodziejczyk's estimate of about 2 million (1500 to 1700): medievalists.net; Halil İnalcık and Dariusz Kołodziejczyk in The Cambridge World History of Slavery, vol. 3; Alan W. Fisher, "Muscovy and the Black Sea Slave Trade" (1972); Leslie Peirce, Empress of the East (2017), on Roxelana.
      9. Madeline C. Zilfi, Women and Slavery in the Late Ottoman Empire (Cambridge University Press, 2010); Ehud R. Toledano, The Ottoman Slave Trade and Its Suppression, 1840 to 1890 (Princeton University Press, 1982); Hannah Barker, That Most Precious Merchandise: The Mediterranean Trade in Black Sea Slaves, 1260 to 1500 (2019).
      10. Robert C. Davis, Christian Slaves, Muslim Masters: White Slavery in the Mediterranean, the Barbary Coast and Italy, 1500 to 1800 (Palgrave Macmillan, 2003); Ohio State University, "When Europeans Were Slaves" (2004): osu.edu; Des Ekin, The Stolen Village (2006), on Baltimore; The Travels of Reverend Ólafur Egilsson (2016), on Iceland in 1627.
      11. US Department of State, Office of the Historian, "Barbary Wars, 1801 to 1805 and 1815 to 1816": history.state.gov.
      12. Liam Hogan, Laura McAtackney and Matthew C. Reilly, "The Irish in the Anglo-Caribbean: Servants or Slaves?", History Ireland (2016): historyireland.com; Thomas Bartlett in The Oxford History of the British Empire, vol. 2 (1998); Hilary Beckles, White Servitude and Black Slavery in Barbados (1989).
      13. Abbot Emerson Smith, Colonists in Bondage: White Servitude and Convict Labor in America, 1607 to 1776 (1947); David Galenson, White Servitude in Colonial America (1981).
      14. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, "Forced Labor: An Overview": ushmm.org and "Experiences of Forced Labor in Wartime Europe" (10 to 13 million): ushmm.org; Anne Applebaum, Gulag: A History (2003): cato.org.
      15. SlaveVoyages, Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade Database, estimates (12,521,354 embarked; 10,702,644 landed; 388,744 to mainland North America), read 18 November 2026: slavevoyages.org; Henry Louis Gates Jr., "How Many Slaves Landed in the U.S.?": pbs.org.
      16. Thomas Sowell, interview at the Hoover Institution (clip in the second video, 24:00); Thomas Sowell, "Irresponsible 'Education'", Creators Syndicate, 14 October 2014: creators.com; Black Rednecks and White Liberals (2005).
      17. US Census Bureau, Working Paper 56 (Campbell Gibson and Kay Jung, 2002): 3,953,760 enslaved people in 1860: census.gov.
      18. Carter G. Woodson, Free Negro Owners of Slaves in the United States in 1830 (1924): archive.org; totals of about 3,775 owners and 12,760 enslaved people are later tallies of his lists.
      19. Gomes Eanes de Zurara, Chronicle of the Discovery and Conquest of Guinea (on the 1444 sale at Lagos): miamioh.edu; King Afonso I of Kongo, letter to King João III of Portugal (1526): macmillanusa.com.
      20. Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Zanj rebellion": britannica.com; Nathan Nunn, "The Long-Term Effects of Africa's Slave Trades", Quarterly Journal of Economics (2008): oup.com.
      21. Leland Donald, Aboriginal Slavery on the Northwest Coast of North America (1997): ucpress.edu; James Brooks, Captives and Cousins (2002); Pekka Hämäläinen, The Comanche Empire (2008); Gideon Shelach, "The Qiang and the Question of Human Sacrifice in the Late Shang Period", Asian Perspectives (1996): hawaii.edu; Hellie, Britannica (above), on Korea.
      22. Henry Louis Gates Jr. on C-SPAN (clip in the second video, 39:40 to 41:00, captioned "Henry Louis Gates, Jr., Harvard University History Professor"); Henry Louis Gates Jr., "Ending the Slavery Blame-Game", The New York Times, 22 April 2010: nytimes.com.
      23. UK Parliament, "Parliament abolishes the slave trade": parliament.uk; Historic UK, "The West Africa Squadron": historic-uk.com.
      24. National Archives, Act Prohibiting the Importation of Slaves (1807): docsteach.org; National Archives, 13th Amendment: archives.gov; National Archives, "Black Soldiers in the Civil War": archives.gov; J. David Hacker on Civil War deaths: binghamton.edu.
      25. Abolition in the French colonies (1794 and 1848): unicaen.fr; Clements Library, "Timeline of Emancipation": umich.edu; US Department of State, Trafficking in Persons Report 2002 (Saudi Arabia, royal decree of 1962): refworld.org; Anti-Slavery International on Mauritania (1981 and 2007): antislavery.org.
      26. ILO, Walk Free and IOM, Global Estimates of Modern Slavery (2022): 49.6 million people in 2021: walkfree.org.

      What we checked in the videos

      The two videos get the big picture right. A few of their numbers do not hold up, so this site leaves them out or corrects them:

      • "Laws on slaves 4,000 years before Christ." The oldest tablets that list slaves are from about 3200 BC, and the oldest law code about 2100 BC.
      • "A third of Italy's population was enslaved." One in three is the top of historians' range; the usual estimate is about one in five to one in three, for Italy only.
      • "The Romans and ancient Greeks enslaved the Slavs." The Slavs first appear in written records in the 500s AD. The word "slave" comes from the Middle Ages.
      • "Algiers held 25,000 to 35,000 slaves." That is the estimate for all the Barbary states together in the 1600s, most of them in Algiers.
      • "The 1805 war ended white slavery in North Africa." It went on until the bombardment of Algiers in 1816 and the French conquest from 1830.
      • "More Europeans were enslaved by North Africans than Africans shipped to the Western Hemisphere." About 1 to 1.25 million against about 12.5 million. Thomas Sowell's comparison is with the United States only, about 388,000, and there it holds.
      • "The Arab and Ottoman trades enslaved tens of millions more than the Atlantic trade." Estimates for the trade of Africans into the Muslim world are wide, roughly 10 to 18 million over about 1,300 years: comparable to the Atlantic's 12.5 million, not tens of millions more. For the years 1400 to 1900 the Atlantic trade was about twice as large.
      • "Half a million Zanj rebels." No source gives that. The revolt began with work gangs of 500 to 5,000 men.
      • "300,000 Irish sold as slaves", "100,000 Irish children sold" and "the Irish were the largest source of slaves". No records support these numbers. By 1653 Barbados had about 20,000 enslaved Africans and 8,000 indentured servants of all origins. The documented story of the 1650s is told above.
      • "To Hell or to Connacht" as a proclamation. Historians say the Cromwellians never proclaimed it; the real 1654 order moved Catholic landowners west, and it was about land.
      • "Africans were almost worthless to the Ottomans." Not true: African eunuchs were among the most expensive slaves of all.
      • "Nearly half a million white Americans died to abolish slavery." About 360,000 Union soldiers died, including tens of thousands of Black soldiers. The Confederate dead fought to keep slavery.
      • "The USA was one of the first major nations to outlaw slavery." Mexico (1829), Britain (1833) and France (1848) ended it earlier.
      • "In some years the British squadron freed more Africans than the whole trade carried." It freed about 150,000 people in total while about 3.5 million were still shipped.